In recent decades, comic book films have dominated cinema. In doing so, they have often struggled to break free from the “rules” of their niche. Trying to shatter these shackles, Clayface is a new film that injects a horror flavour into the DC universe. Written by Mike Flanagan & Hossein Amini and directed by James Watkins, this movie is a welcome exploration of the limits of comic book cinema.
As he reaches the height of his acting career, a charismatic leading man finds himself on a path of revenge after being horribly disfigured. Tom Rhys Harries stars, with a supporting cast that includes Naomi Ackie, David Dencik and Max Minghella.
Clayface is not a perfect piece of comic book cinema. For example, the central villain is incredibly miscast; the role would have been better served by a more imposing actor. Furthermore, the film often struggles with pacing, leaving large sections feeling like they are treading water. However, the movie offers something unique, and it is here, where it takes chances, that it excels the most.
In the same way that 2019’s Joker acted as a gateway drug to more complex character studies, Clayface may be an excellent starter film for those intrigued by horror. This isn’t an insult either, as the movie quite elegantly rides a line between brutality and commercial viability. While some viewers may have wished that the violence went further, the gore that we do get is a joy to witness.
Tom Rhys Harries is a great pick as the morally dubious protagonist of this picture. As previously mentioned, some other characters are miscast, but there are just as many more that do an impressive job. In a small role, Corey Johnson practically steals the show for the few scenes that he is in.
A particular area where the film shines is how it uses “comic book powers” to elevate the story. There is a lot of emotionality writhing in this movie’s underbelly. In dissecting these elements, the filmmakers smartly utilise fantastical tools to their benefit. This isn’t a film that is embarrassed to be set in a world of superheroes; it accepts its reality from the get-go and creates its own lane from there.
Clayface is a refreshing release for the DC Universe. It may not be perfect, but what it offers in delivering a comic book story wrapped in an unexplored genre is exactly what franchise cinema needs right now. Because of this, Clayface can be recommended to both fans and non-fans of superheroes alike.